Pumpkin Spice Jewelry Ideas for a Festive Fall Look
If you’re not one, you know one: The person who eagerly awaits Starbucks to release their Pumpkin Spice Latte every year. They’re first in line to order one, even if it’s still 80 degrees outside, and the person who puts up their Halloween décor right after Labor Day. They start donning sweaters before the weather is right, and they live, breathe, eat, and drink all things fall — their favorite and happiest time of year.
As the pumpkin spice craze has only grown over the years, the trend is infiltrating just about every edge of culture. From cosmetics to cereals, candles to cookies, pumpkin spice is everywhere and in everything — but what about your jewelry?
Here are some pumpkin spice jewelry ideas for the diehard fall fans.
What You Will Learn
Pumpkin Spice-Colored Gemstones

1. Madeira Citrine
As the name suggests, citrine often exhibits a citrus-y hue that’s more appropriate for summer, but you can find shades of orange, too. Madeira citrine is a member of the quartz family that’s heat-treated to achieve the desirable orange-brown appearance. It gets its name from the Brazilian word for “wood.”
2. Orange Sapphires
Did you know that sapphires come in far more colors than merely bright blue? The stone can also carry various hues ranging from white to black to green to purple to pink to, yes, orange.
Orange sapphires can be rare compared to some of these other pumpkin spice-colored gemstones. Additionally, since they’re so rare to find in nature, many are heat-treated to achieve optimum levels of orange. Like most sapphires, they also display a range of shades, from light to deep orange.
3. Hessonite Garnet
This gemstone boasts the perfect nickname for fall: the cinnamon stone. Although, hessonite garnets range in color from a lighter yellow-orange to a dark, red-brown orange. These garnets haven’t always been the most popular, but that means one great thing for you: more affordable prices. Just note that hessonite garnets may not be as durable as some other gemstones, as they rank lower on the Mohs scale and can be easily scratched through daily wear and tear.
4. Imperial Topaz
Like citrine, topaz is most commonly known as a yellow stone, but imperial topaz is a variety that shows beautiful shades of orange. Historically, it was mined in Russia’s Ural Mountains and was prized by the imperial leadership of the 1800s, but it’s now mostly mined in Brazil.
5. Carnelian
Carnelian is a type of quartz known as chalcedony. This is a very unique stone since, rather than offering a sparkly, clear appearance (like an orange sapphire), it’s opaque with vibrant shades of red, orange, and brown. Carnelian has long been prized for its appearance and symbolism, and you can find it in an array of designer pieces, such as those produced by Van Cleef & Arpels.
6. Amber
Amber is not a gemstone (technically, it’s a fossilized tree resin) but is found in beautiful jewelry pieces. Polished amber might be golden-yellow, orange, or red-brown (or, on rare occasions, blue or green). Amber can also be cloudy or transparent — some transparent amber will show off interesting inclusions that can be particularly eye-catching. Amber makes for a great pendant, and amber beads can be incorporated into necklaces or bracelets.
Warm-Toned Precious Metals
You’ll need some warm-toned precious metals to complement your pumpkin spice gemstones. Great options include:
- Yellow gold
- Rose gold
- Copper
- Brass
- Bronze
Just note that not all warm-toned metals are best for every jewelry wearer. For example, bronze is a metal alloy containing small amounts of metals like nickel, which may be a common cause of jewelry rashes and allergies.
Meanwhile, some metals may be more durable and scratch-resistant than others. For example, you might be surprised to learn that brass is harder and more durable than gold when you compare gold and brass. It ranks a 3–4 on the Mohs scale, while gold ranks a 2.5.
Fall and Nature-Centric Motifs
Nature-centric themes have gone in and out of fashion throughout the ages. Victorians appreciated floral and nature designs, as did jewelry wearers in the Art Nouveau era. More recently, nature-inspired designs have made a comeback, and incorporating them into your look can make for a unique nod to pumpkin spice season.
Look for pieces of jewelry that have motifs such as…
- Leaves
- Acorns
- Feathers
- Gourds
You don’t have to go kitschy or look to only costume jewelry for fall and nature-centric motifs, either. Various designer brands, such as Van Cleef & Arpels, Tiffany & Co., and Cartier, embrace natural elements throughout their collections.
Suggested Read: Nature Inspired Engagement Rings
Pumpkin Spice Jewelry Ideas FAQs
What Fall Jewelry Will Be Best for Me?
Picking a new piece of jewelry is a very personal decision that will depend on various factors. Before buying pumpkin spice jewelry, think about its purpose, durability, care needs, and price — and then see how those factors align with your lifestyle, fashion sense, and budget.
Can You Wear Fall Jewelry Year-Round?
Yes, you can wear fall jewelry all year! For the greatest versatility throughout the seasons, pick a classic piece that goes with everything, such as a statement ring with an orange gemstone, or a pair of stud earrings in a warm-toned precious metal.
How Much Will Pumpkin Spice Jewelry Cost?
All jewelry comes in a wide variety of price points. You can purchase fall-themed jewelry from local makers or on platforms like Etsy for a budget (under $100). But if you want to spend a little more, visit a local jewelry chain. If you have a designer budget, you can find fall-appropriate jewelry, designs, and gemstones from many high-end brands.
Can You Make Your Own Pumpkin Spice Jewelry?
Yes! You can find plenty of fall jewelry-making supplies at major craft stores. Try your hand at making DIY earrings, pendants, bracelets, and more, right at home.
Is Pumpkin Spice Jewelry Kitschy?
It’s only as kitschy as you want it to be! If you love costume jewelry, you can go all out with jewelry that displays pumpkins, ghosts, or even pendants that directly spell out your love for all things pumpkin spice. But if you want to go the more demure route, stick to warm gemstones, metals, and motifs that reflect the season more delicately.
Protect Your Jewelry in All Seasons with BriteCo
Whether you’re buying a pumpkin spice statement ring from your local jewelry chain or a holiday pendant, protect your pieces all year with BriteCo’s comprehensive jewelry insurance. From mysterious disappearance to loss to theft, we protect it all, covering up to 125% of the value of your piece in replacements and repairs.
Get your free jewelry insurance quote now.
Related Article:


