Jewelry Trends

Is an Antique Cut Diamond Right for You?

Rachel Akmakjian


Rachel Akmakjian

Timeless Beauty: The Charm of an Antique Cut Diamond for Your Engagement Ring

While modern diamonds like the brilliant cut diamond or princess cut may be popular today, what happens if you take a step back in time? You’ll discover a timeless beauty within the enchanting world of antique diamonds. Whether it’s the delicate charm of a rose cut diamond, the rich history of an old mine cut diamond, or the classic elegance of an old European cut diamond, each antique cut tells a unique story.

Keep reading to learn the basics of the three main antique diamond cuts: rose cut diamonds, old mine cut diamonds, and old European cut diamonds, as well as some helpful tips on how to shop for antique diamonds to ensure you’re getting the best vintage diamond for your money.

What You Will Learn

Why Choose an Antique Cut Diamond for Your Engagement Ring?

  1. Unique Character: Vintage diamonds offer a distinct character that differentiates them from modern cuts. Their imperfections and idiosyncrasies tell a story and add depth to the ring’s overall design.
  2. Timeless Appeal: Vintage diamond cuts have withstood the test of time, holding a sense of enduring beauty. They bring nostalgia and charm that resonates with those who appreciate the aesthetics of the past.
  3. Sustainability: Choosing a vintage diamond is an eco-friendly option. Opting for a pre-owned stone reduces the demand for new diamond mining, minimizing the industry’s environmental impact.
    Suggested Read: Vintage Style Engagement Rings | BriteCo Jewelry Insurance

antique cut diamond Info

Rose Cut Diamonds: Romantic and Delicate

Imagine the intricate petals of a blooming rose delicately reflected in the facets of a diamond. That’s the beauty of a rose cut diamond. 

Originating in the 1500s, the rose cut features a flat bottom and a dome-shaped top adorned with triangular facets. The rose cut diamond offers a romantic, vintage feel, and its unique silhouette shines with subtle elegance. While it doesn’t boast the intense sparkle of modern cuts, it has its own charm, perfect for those who appreciate timeless grace and understated beauty.

Rose Cut Diamonds | BriteCo Jewelry Insurance

antique cut diamond

Old Mine Cut Diamonds: A Window to the Past

If you’re captivated by history and vintage allure, an old mine cut diamond might be your ideal choice. 


Originating in the 18th century, this cut is known for its slightly irregular shape and large, high crown. The vintage diamond shape resembles a cushion cut, with a rounded-square silhouette. Old mine cuts showcase a unique pattern of larger, chunky facets that create mesmerizing flashes of light, giving the stone a captivating antique glow. While it may not have the precise symmetry of modern cuts, this cut’s individuality and rich history make it a cherished symbol of your love story.

Should I Get an Old Mine Cut Diamond for My Engagement Ring? | BriteCo Jewelry Insurance

Old European Cut Diamonds: Classic Elegance with a Modern Twist

The old European cut diamond is a perfect blend of both vintage charm and remarkable brilliance. 

Developed in the late 19th century, this cut represents a transitional period between old mine cuts and modern brilliant cuts. With a round shape and a higher crown, it features an increased number of facets, enhancing its brilliance and fire. The old European cut is an exquisite choice for an engagement ring that stands the test of time.

Shopping Tips for Antique Cut Diamonds

  1. Educate Yourself: Learn about different antique diamond cuts, their characteristics, and their historical significance. This knowledge will help you make an informed decision and appreciate each cut’s unique qualities.
  2. Use Trustworthy Jewelers: Seek reputable jewelers who specialize in antique diamonds. Look for certifications and ask for detailed information about any diamond’s origins and any necessary repairs or restoration work.
  3. Ask for Certification: Inspect the diamond under proper lighting conditions and consider getting it independently certified to verify its authenticity, quality, and value.
  4. Stay True to Your Personal Preference: Ultimately, choose a diamond that resonates with you and your partner. Although a vintage diamond offers a one-of-a-kind charm, they’re not the right choice for everyone, and there are plenty of modern options just as beautiful and eco-conscious.
  5. Keep Your Diamond  Protected with Specialized Jewelry Insurance: Proper insurance is necessary for ALL diamond jewelry, and thanks to BriteCo, keeping your diamonds protected is more affordable and easier than ever.

BriteCo offers specialty jewelry insurance that covers up to 125% of your ring’s appraised value. Our policy covers loss, theft, damage, and even mysterious disappearance. 

Get an instant free quote for a budget-friendly monthly or annual payment. From there, all you have to do is upload the required documentation, and you’ll have coverage in minutes.

Also Check:

How Are Diamonds Cut? | BriteCo Jewelry Insurance
Unveiling the Brilliance of the Trilliant Cut Diamond 
Unique Diamond Shapes: The Lozenge Cut Diamond
Square Emerald Cut Diamond | BriteCo Jewelry Insurance


Buying Guide:

The Secret to Diamond Buying: Natural vs Lab Grown



UP NEXT: Types of Chains

Rachel's expertise is further enhanced by her distinction as a Graduate Gemologist from the prestigious Gemological Institute of America (GIA), equipping her with exceptional knowledge in gem identification and grading. Her education and experiences have given her an in-depth understanding of the demands and expectations facing jewelers and customers in today’s evolving retail marketplace.