Engagement Ring Advice

December is Proposal Season: What the Data Says About Holiday Engagements

Dustin Lemick

Author

Dustin Lemick

Published:

November 16th, 2026

December is Proposal Season: What the Data Says About Holiday Engagements

December and the holiday season in general are part of what’s known as engagement season, a time when it seems like more people are popping the question than ever. BriteCo’s Jewelry, Diamond, & Watch Price Index supports this, finding that, from 2019 to 2025, December has accounted for 10.4% of all engagement rings appraisals, more than any other month. 

(It is worth noting that appraisal timing doesn’t concretely indicate when a proposal happened, but there’s plenty of other evidence, such as research from The Knot, to support the popularity of holiday engagements.)

If you’re planning a holiday proposal yourself, you’re probably already thinking about ring budgets, diamond choices, shopping deadlines, and protecting the purchase. Let’s discuss all of the above, and hear from a voice of experience: private jeweler Kellie Alkayam of Lilit Fine Jewelry in Lakewood, Colorado. December is proposal season: Here’s what the data says about holiday engagements.

What You Will Learn

Why is December Considered Proposal Season?

December is considered proposal season because it’s not just one of the most popular months, it is the most popular month to get engaged, with many individuals proposing on Christmas Eve, Christmas Day, or New Year’s Eve.

many individuals proposing on Christmas Eve, Christmas Day, or New Year’s Eve.

As mentioned, BriteCo’s data surrounding engagement ring appraisals supports the existence of proposal season further, with December being the most popular month to seek out an engagement ring appraisal. As you can see in the table below, December ranks highest, accounting for 10.4% of appraisals.

Month Share of BriteCo engagement ring appraisals
December 10.4%
October 9.8%
November 9.1%
February 6.5%

Engagement-ring appraisal activity, complete-year series covering 2019–2025. Source: BriteCo.

Appraisal Activity and Proposal Dates Measure Different Things

Of course, getting an appraisal in December doesn’t always mean that the couple had a December engagement. Appraisal, ring purchase, and proposal dates can all differ vastly, by months or even years. 

So, a December appraisal could precede or follow a proposal. Still, research from The Knot has found December is the most popular month to propose, in nearly every country around the world.

Choosing a Holiday Date That Fits Your Relationship

Choosing a Holiday Date That Fits Your Relationship

If you want to propose in December, don’t feel pressured to propose on Christmas Day, Christmas Eve, or New Year’s Eve, unless that’s really what you and your partner would like most. You want to plan a proposal that feels personal vs. picking a date that’s popular.

don’t feel pressured to propose on Christmas Day, Christmas Eve, or New Year’s Eve, unless that’s really what you and your partner would like most

Keep in mind, too, that family gatherings, traditions, and time available together can differ across these holidays. These considerations may impact how the big moment goes down. 

How Much Are Couples Spending on Engagement Rings?

According to BriteCo data, the median engagement ring sales price increased from $6,072 in 2019 to $6,939 in 2025, a nominal increase of 14.3%.

Year Median engagement-ring sales price
2019 $6,072
2025 $6,939

Note that these are annual medians, not December-specific prices. Additionally, the data indicates an increase between 2019 and 2025; the data does not indicate uninterrupted annual growth, so prices could have potentially decreased at some point between 2019 and 2025. The figures are also not adjusted for inflation.

As you consider these median prices, keep in mind that they’re not a requirement or what everyone is spending. Alkayam, for example, notes that most of her engagement ring buyers “are younger and a lot of them don’t have a ton of money to spend,” so they stick to a $3,000-$5,000 price range. You should pick a comfortable engagement ring budget that fits your finances without causing undue stress, so you can feel confident and secure as you continue planning your dream proposal.

Natural Vs. Lab-Grown Diamonds: What Are Holiday Shoppers Paying?

According to BriteCo’s data, in 2025, natural diamond engagement rings had a median sales price of $12,961, while the median sales price for lab-grown diamond rings was $4,557.

What Are Holiday Shoppers Paying?

It’s worth clarifying that these are median sales prices for each group. The two prices are not a direct comparison between one natural and one lab-grown ring that are otherwise identical in size, quality, setting, and similar characteristics.

But anyone shopping for diamonds can see the major price difference. Says Alkayam, “I’ve had customers who are like, ‘My girlfriend wants lab-grown.’ And I quote them for a 4-carat and they say, “That’s it?
I feel like I’m being cheap. How can I spend more?’ ”

A lot goes into determining the price of an engagement ring, and diamond origin is just one of those facets.

Are Lab-Grown Diamonds Becoming More Popular?

According to BriteCo data, lab-grown diamonds represented 47% of newly appraised engagement rings in 2025, compared to just 5.9% in 2019.

The shift has been even more striking for Alkayam, who estimates that her diamond engagement ring sales are “95% lab grown, 5% natural, and the natural diamonds are salt and pepper. Almost nobody asks me for natural.”

Are Engagement-Ring Diamonds Getting Bigger?

According to BriteCo data, the median engagement-ring center-stone size (center stone only, not total carat weight) increased from 1.01 carats in 2019 to 2.0 carats in 2025.

This could be in part due to many couples now choosing lab-grown diamonds, which are more affordable, allowing the purchase of larger diamonds. “I think people always wanted bigger stones, but they couldn’t afford it,” Alkayam says. “And so now that they can, that turns out that’s what they wanted all along.”

However, there’s no direct proof that the two data trends — the greater adoption of lab-grown diamonds and the increase in stone size — are an example of causation rather than mere correlation.

If you’re choosing between natural and lab-grown diamonds for your holiday proposal, keep more than just budget in mind. You’ll want to balance both the budgetary implications and the preferences of your future other half, so that you purchase a ring your partner loves.

When Should You Start Shopping for a December Proposal?

If your wedding planning includes a December proposal, begin your ring research in advance, in early fall, for the greatest flexibility. You may still be able to find and purchase rings into late November.  

Alkayam suggests starting the process three months before you plan to pop the question. “Sometimes people need some time to think about it,” she says. “I’ve found that it’s taking people longer than it used to to make decisions. I have to nurture them more. We work on the design and then I start sourcing stones and then they pick one and then the piece goes into production.” 

What stage are you in? What to think about
You’re planning an engagement ring purchase but are in the early research stage Your budget, your partner’s style preferences, their preferences related to diamond origin, and sizing needs
You’ve done your research and now want to order a ring The ring’s availability, scheduling needs related to custom work, what you’ll do for resizing needs, and the seller’s return terms
You’re ready to buy a ring but have holiday travel coming up The ring’s purchase or delivery date, collection arrangements if necessary, documentation to ensure the ring’s safety, and secure storage for the ring box while traveling
You have the ring and are ready to propose Will the ring fit? Do you have insurance coverage for it? Where will the ring live after the proposal?


Keep the Occasion Personal

Once you’ve secured your perfect ring, start thinking about holiday and/or Christmas proposal ideas. There are many, many options.

  • If you live together, you could propose during a private moment next to the Christmas tree
  • If you want to go to a secondary location, you might pick a meaningful spot that just so happens to be decorated with seasonal fairy lights (perfect for a photo op!)
  • If your partner is very close to their loved ones, you might plan to propose as part of the family celebration

Before picking any specific option, think about your partner’s preferences. “If your partner’s a very private person, please do not do it publicly,” Alkayam says. “They’re probably not going to like that.” Some may even prefer to avoid a surprise all together!

Should You Insure an Engagement Ring Before Proposing?

As soon as you have an engagement ring in your possession, you should take steps to protect it with proper insurance coverage. Anything can occur to the ring once it’s left the jeweler or arrived on your doorstep via delivery, and risks increase if you’re storing the ring ahead of proposing or traveling with it. Theft, loss, damage, and mysterious disappearance are more likely than you might think.

As soon as you have an engagement ring in your possession, you should take steps to protect it with proper insurance coverage

And if something were to occur, you might just be surprised at the cost to replace the ring with an identical one. According to BriteCo data, the median engagement-ring sales price was $6,939 in 2025, but the median appraised replacement value was $9,676.

Appraised replacement value is how much it’s estimated to cost to replace a ring after a loss. It differs so starkly from the original sales price due to changing markets, demand, and similar factors.

(Note that this gap is in no way a guaranteed loss or payout for a ring owner after an insurance claim.)

So, before you take the big step of proposing, or even store or travel with the ring, arrange for jewelry insurance. When you do, confirm who will be insured (you, your fiancé-to-be, or both of you), when the coverage is active, what documentation you need, and any changes to the policy that will be needed post-proposal.

Frequently Asked Questions About December Proposals

Is Christmas Day More Popular Than Valentine’s Day for Proposals?

Yes, according to research from The Knot, Christmas Day is more popular than Valentine’s Day for a marriage proposal.

Can New Year’s Day Be a Good Proposal Date?

Yes, New Year’s Day can be a good proposal date — it all just depends on your preferences as a couple, traditions, timeline, obligations on the holiday, etc. Ultimately, you should choose the day to propose that works best for the both of you, not what is most popular or trending.

Are Engagement Rings Cheaper During Holiday Sales?

BriteCo’s data does not indicate that engagement rings are cheaper during the month of December, such as during holiday sales. Before purchasing a ring, evaluate your budget and compare rings based on their actual specifications, seller terms, and what you might get for a comparable price elsewhere.

Should You Insure the Ring Before Proposing?

Yes, you should always insure a new engagement ring as soon as it is in your possession. Before you propose, travel with the ring, or store the ring, secure coverage to protect your investment in the event of loss, theft, accidental damage, or mysterious disappearance.

When Should You Buy a Ring for a December Proposal?

You should start shopping for a ring for a December proposal early enough that you’ll have a wide array of ring inventory to choose from, as well as early enough to have time for any custom work and sizing. Take delivery deadlines into account as well. For some, this may mean you only have to start shopping in November, but others may need to start earlier.

Planning a December Proposal? Prepare the Ring Before the Big Day

December is the leading month for BriteCo engagement ring appraisals, correlating with December being the most popular month for engagements. However, that doesn’t mean you have to get engaged in December — just like you don’t have to align your engagement ring budget with 2025 median sales prices.

Your and your partner’s personal preferences regarding budget, when to propose, and more should all take precedence.

Whatever you end up doing, though, insurance coverage is key to protecting the ring before it has a chance to be exposed to a potential loss. Explore engagement ring insurance and confirm when you need coverage to begin.

Quiz:

The Engagement Ring Calculator You’ve Been Searching For and it’s FREE!

START YOUR COMPARISON NOW →

START YOUR COMPARISON NOW
Share

UP NEXT: Which States Spend the Most on Engagement Rings? New Yorkers Spend the Most, State-by-State Data Finds

Dustin Lemick

Author

Dustin Lemick

Dustin Lemick is the Founder and CEO of BriteCo and a third-generation jeweler with over thirteen years of retail jewelry experience. He holds a Graduate Gemologist degree from the Gemological Institute of America (GIA) and has in-depth knowledge and expertise in appraisal systems, diamond and gemstone markets, retail pricing models, insurance replacement models, and jewelry quotation pricing systems.