Jewelry Protection

Kay Jewelers Ring Insurance: How It Works

Dustin Lemick

Author

Dustin Lemick

Updated on:

October 13th, 2025

Kay Jewelers Ring Insurance

Kay Jewelers Ring Insurance

“Every kiss begins with Kay.” How many times have you heard that jingle? Given the chain’s popularity, it should come as no surprise that many individuals buy their engagement rings at one of the brand’s many stores across America. You probably have lots to consider if you’re among them (or planning to be). How do you pick the perfect engagement ring? How do you pop the question? What kind of engagement ring styles does the chain offer?

Once you’ve figured all that out, there’s one last thing you need to do: Ensure your new ring is protected in unfortunate circumstances like loss or theft. This is where Kay Jewelers ring insurance can help.

Diamond engagement ring on flower

What You Will Learn

Kay Jewelers Insurance on Rings & Other Purchases

When you buy your engagement ring from Kay Jewelers, you’ll automatically receive the chain’s lifetime diamond and gemstone guarantee (if your ring includes a diamond, sapphire, emerald, or ruby), and you’ll also be offered a few protection plan options. These protection plans are what the brand provides versus more traditional Kay Jewelers engagement ring insurance.

The diamond and gemstone guarantee ensures that if your ring’s centerpiece is chipped, broken, or lost during normal wear, you can have it replaced free of charge. However, it’s important to note that for this guarantee to remain effective, you must have your ring inspected at a Kay Jewelers location every six months.

Kay Jewelers’ other plans include the Forever Cherished Lifetime Protection Plan, specifically designed for engagement rings, wedding bands, and anniversary bands, and the broader lifetime protection plan, applicable to all other jewelry.

If you’re looking for an engagement ring, you’ll likely consider purchasing the former. It provides free repairs or replacements if the ring “fails” during normal wear or due to defects. It also allows for free resizing to a certain degree.

Exceptions to Kay Jewelers’ Coverage

However, there’s a whole lot the brand’s protection plan doesn’t cover, including:

  • Incidental damages
  • Loss
  • Theft
  • Mysterious disappearance
  • Damage due to “acts of God” (extreme weather events, for example)

But, if you lose your engagement ring, it’s stolen, or damaged in a way that Kay Jewelers deems to be your fault and beyond normal wear and tear, you’re on your own when it comes to repairing or replacing the ring.

What Will Truly Protect Your Kay Jewelers Engagement Ring?

Comprehensive coverage

If you want comprehensive coverage to replace or repair your engagement ring if or when the worst happens, you’ll want jewelry insurance. Specialty jewelry insurance stands apart from a traditional warranty or protection plan as it generally provides broader coverage.

BriteCo’s specialty jewelry insurance covers

If any of these incidents occur, BriteCo’s clients can submit a quick and easy claim online and then receive a generous payout to replace or repair the covered jewelry.

But What About Existing Insurance?

It’s a good question. If you already have homeowners or renters insurance, you might think your policy will protect your engagement ring and any other jewelry you own.

While these policies do include some jewelry coverage, it’s typically very minimal, with small payouts and many exclusions.

For example, while a homeowners or renters insurance policy may cover a ring that’s stolen or damaged in a natural disaster like a fire, it won’t cover if you simply lose your ring or damage it during normal wear. And, even if your homeowners or renters policy covers your claim, the provider likely will not pay enough to replace or repair it in full. Most jewelry owners still have to pay a good portion of the cost, even after insurance.

Homeowners or renters insurance policy coverage

Kay Jewelers Engagement Ring Insurance FAQs

How Can You Get Kay Jewelers Insurance & Lost Ring Coverage?

Unfortunately, Kay Jewelers’ protection plans do not replace lost rings. If you’d like coverage that will help you replace a lost piece of jewelry, consider investing in specialized jewelry insurance.

What Does Engagement Ring Insurance Cover?

BriteCo’s engagement ring insurance policies cover theft, loss, damage, and mysterious disappearance, even while you’re traveling. We provide up to 125% of your piece’s appraised value to cover any needed repairs or a replacement of equal value.

How Much Does It Cost to Insure an Engagement Ring?

BriteCo’s policies typically cost about 1–2% of your ring’s total value per year. So, if you purchased an engagement ring for around $5,000 (the national average), you can expect to pay $50–$100 annually to insure the ring.

Will My Homeowners Insurance Cover My Engagement Ring?

Your homeowners insurance will cover your engagement ring to a small degree. Your policy may give you a minimal payout amount (usually around $1,500) if your ring is stolen or is damaged during an event typically covered by your homeowners insurance, such as a fire.

How Often Do You Have to Pay for Engagement Ring Insurance?

When you purchase a BriteCo engagement ring insurance policy, you can choose to pay for your policy as one annual fee (which comes with a discount) or every month.

Ready to Invest in Specialized Jewelry Insurance? BriteCo Is Here for You

When you’re ready to give your jewelry the protection that it needs, the process is very straightforward. All you have to do is fill out BriteCo’s quick and easy online form. You’ll receive a quote the same day and then choose if you’d like to pay for your policy monthly or annually. BriteCo’s premiums are incredibly affordable, typically starting around 1% of your jewelry’s total value.

If you ever need to file a claim, the process is just as seamless. You can do so online, and BriteCo will quickly process the information, paying out as much as 125% of your jewelry’s value, covering all your repairs and replacement costs.

Learn more about BriteCo’s comprehensive coverage and get your quote now.

Related Articles:

Zales Ring Insurance: Why It’s So Important to Have
JCPenney Ring Insurance: What You Need to Know
Pandora Ring Insurance
Shane Co Ring Insurance
The Ring Insurance Blue Nile Pieces Deserve

Quiz:

The Engagement Ring Calculator You’ve Been Searching For and it’s FREE!

START YOUR COMPARISON NOW

START YOUR COMPARISON NOW
Share

UP NEXT: How to Insure Jewelry: A Step-by-Step Guide

Dustin Lemick

Author

Dustin Lemick

Dustin Lemick is the Founder and CEO of BriteCo and a third-generation jeweler with over thirteen years of retail jewelry experience. He holds a Graduate Gemologist degree from the Gemological Institute of America (GIA) and has in-depth knowledge and expertise in appraisal systems, diamond and gemstone markets, retail pricing models, insurance replacement models, and jewelry quotation pricing systems.